Graeme Clarke homepage
Call Today: (03) 348-5595

What do you deduce Watson?

Comments Off on What do you deduce Watson?

Sherlock Holmes and Dr Watson go on a Camping trip.

After a good Dinner and a bottle of Wine, they retire for the night and go to sleep.

Some hours later, Holmes wakes up and nudges his faithful friend. “Watson, look up at the sky and tell me what you see.”

“I see millions of stars, Holmes” replies Watson.

“And what do you deduce from that?”

Watson ponders for a minute. “Well,

Astronomically, it tells me there are millions of galaxies and potentially billions of planets

Astrologically, I observe that Saturn is in Leo
Horologically I deduce the time is approximately a quarter past three
Meteorologically I suspect we will have a beautiful day tomorrow.
Theologically I can see a god that is all-powerful, and that we are small and insignificant in the universe.

But what does it tell you Holmes? “

Holmes is silent for a minute.

Watson you idiot ! He says: “Someone has stolen our tent! “

Well I got a giggle from that as did many as this tale was rated the second best joke from a study carried out at the University of Hertfordshire.

To find things funny we need to be able to shift perspective, see paradoxes, be surprised and delighted by the unexpected, the punchline. We are in a state of observing which gives us space. The emotion created by humour is called mirth, which can go from a mild amusement to side-splitting hilarity.

Laughter or ‘Vitamin H’ is good for our bodies and minds, increasing our oxygen intake, producing hormones that relax muscles, strengthening the immune system, lowering blood pressure and easing digestion. Physiologically there is an increase in dopamine activity in the pleasure or ‘reward’ centres of the brain. Our pain thresholds also increase, and a relaxation response is triggered, causing our legs and arms to become weak.

Beneficial humour is called ‘self enhancing’. It is being able to laugh at ourselves (self depreciating) and see the humour in our circumstance. There is also a form of humour which is aggressive or self defeating, used at someone else’s expense e.g. sarcasm, schadenfreude (delight in others misfortune).

The ability to step back and observe, and to find humour is a positive indicator of emotional health.

There is this elegant, helpful way of categorising some emotional states. If we are ‘high arousal’ and ‘low stress’ there is a pleasant excitement. If we are ‘high arousal’ and ‘high stress’ there is anxiety, and constant anxiety drains our emotional resources, and perspective.

In our quake ravaged city and rebuild, the stressors remain constant for many. It is certainly no fun dealing with ongoing stress at multiple levels.

For the many who are ravished by constant post quake demands the ‘high arousal’ ‘high stress’ burnout state exists. Many of the clients I have seen talk of feeling detached, numbed, and struggle to step back and gain perspective. The fact that 66,000 Cantabrians are on antidepressant medication is an indicator of the need to buffer the level of distress.

There are many constructive ways of trying to reduce that stress. Finding things that are ‘doable’ and manageable, maintaining simple routines, talking to friends and family, mild regular exercise, and giving ourselves permission to relax… treating ourselves in some basic way…and focusing on the issues we have some control over…

But also keep in mind the benefits of humour.

When we share humour it deepens our connection to others and allows us for a while to be the observer and provides a welcome, albeit temporary reprieve and release…

Not easy for those struggling with traumatic and constant stressors but when we are able to find humor it is a tonic…

Hopefully Watson did recognise the irony of his earnest endeavours to respond to Holme’s question, and both could appreciate the bonding moment.

Graeme Clarke is a Clinical Psychologist specialising in Trauma, Anxiety, Depression, Couples Therapy, Clinical Hypnosis and Sport Psychology. You can learn more about his work at

Posted In: humour health benefits
  • Unit 10, 35 Riccarton Road
    Christchurch 8011
    New Zealand

    Phone: (03) 348 5595